Non-Newtonian Fluid Seminar 01 · Universität Heidelberg
This post is the third part of the script of my seminar talk From Maxwell’s Fluid to the Oldroyd-B Model, translated from Typst to Markdown. The series:
- From Maxwell's Fluid to Oldroyd-B (I): Maxwell's Fluid
- From Maxwell's Fluid to Oldroyd-B (II): Objective Derivatives
- Oldroyd-B Model and Weissenberg Effect (this post)
1. Oldroyd-B Model
Now we have everything to repair the Maxwell model. Roughly speaking, Oldroyd-B is Maxwell with the UCD [Oldroyd, 1950; Morozov & Spagnolie, 2015]: replace the material derivative
Every observer now agrees on this law, since
Let the memory vanish,
2. Why Does the Fluid Climb the Rod?
Stir water with a rod and the surface dips near the rod: a whirlpool. Stir a polymer solution and the opposite happens: the fluid climbs up the rod. This section explains the difference with a simple force balance.
The setup is shown in Figure 1. A rod of radius

Step 1: The Surface Height Shows the Pressure
Below the surface the pressure grows with depth,
The fluid climbs the rod exactly when the pressure is highest at the rod. So we need
Step 2: The Forces on a Small Piece of Fluid
Take a small piece of fluid between
- Required: to move on a circle, the piece needs its mass
times the acceleration towards the axis. - Pressure:
pushes the outer face in, and pushes the inner face out. The net inward force is , i.e. times the volume. - Rubber bands: in a polymer solution, the chains are stretched along the circles and pull like rubber bands with tension
(force per area). Each side face is pulled along the circle with . The two pulls are not parallel: each is tilted towards the axis by , so together they give inwards.

Newton’s law says that pressure and bands together supply the required force:
Dividing by the volume
- Water (
): only the pressure can turn the fluid, so . The pressure and the surface are highest far away: the whirlpool. - Polymer solution: if the bands squeeze harder than needed,
. The pressure piles up at the rod, and the fluid climbs.
Step 3: The Surface Shape
Since I don’t want to introduce too many technicalities, I will directly give you the result:
Inertia decays like
Dividing by
At the rod,

Both terms carry
- Water (
): a whirlpool. - Polymer solution, thin rod: it climbs!
3. Anecdote: Why not Oldroyd-A?
Oldroyd’s 1950 paper [Oldroyd, 1950] actually proposed two models. Model B uses the upper-convected derivative, as above; model A uses the lower-convected one,
In steady shear both give the same first normal stress difference
Tension along the streamlines. The rubber bands squeeze inwards, and the fluid climbs.
Compression across the streamlines. The fluid is pushed outwards, and the whirlpool dips even deeper.
Weissenberg had seen the fluid climb, so B won [Hinch & Harlen, 2021]. This matches the microscopic picture from the boat ride: polymer chains are line elements, and line elements are carried by the UCD.